How To Accurately Forecast SEO Success Before Content Publication

Utilise this five-step method to de-risk SEO and content preparation and guarantee that you’re concentrating on the things that are most likely to yield benefits.

Only the most dishonest SEOs will “promise” anything.

Only in the deepest, darkest caverns of spammy LinkedIn InMails do “guaranteed” first position rankings, “guaranteed” traffic estimations, and “guaranteed” ROI exist. And only the unwary, gullible, and foolish firms fall for these blatant lies.


That does not imply that you can’t predict or forecast search ROI, traffic projections, or page ranks.

The distinction is in the details and the context.

If you know what you’re doing, you can anticipate the likelihood of success or failure, even before creating a single link for a keyword or before writing a single piece of content.

Why Ranking Takes Ages

It can take a very long time to rank for something new.

For already large sites, it takes weeks to months; for smaller ones, it takes years. And that’s the reason why it’s difficult to “promise” much more accurately in SEO.

Here are a few typical motives.


To rank for desirable keywords, your website must be significant.

But before creating a large website, you must rank for good keywords. Your initial problem is there.

Outputs vs Inputs

The trailing indications are sales, traffic, and rankings.

This means that instead of concentrating on the “outputs,” which may not even be visible for years, we should focus on leading indicators like keyword and topic choices.

Balancing Act

Choosing “excellent” keywords requires striking a balance between:

  • Relevance.
  • Demand.
  • Competitiveness.
  • Authority.
  • Purchasing intent

There needs to be a balance that works perfectly, however. And depending on your short-term versus long-term goals, you frequently have to give up certain features or put others first.

Less “at bats.”

Zero-click SERPs, knowledge graphs, rapid responses, new ad spots, queries that people have also asked, integrated SERPs, and more indicate that:

Less organic spots are available for you to rank in, and those are being relegated to the fold’s very bottom.

The Bar Continues to Rise

Your competition, both direct and indirect, is developing greater financial sophistication. Thus, there is a race to the top.

Every business, brand, or person attempting to rank anything today is impacted by these issues.

And over the coming days, weeks, months, and years, every one of these issues will only worsen.

The ranking was straightforward more than ten years ago. Then, several algorithm changes, including Panda, Penguin, and others, wholly altered everything.

Now that AI and search monopolies have created an increasingly complex environment, we must all learn to navigate it.

How To Accurately Forecast Success

Working with hundreds of businesses over the past 10 years across various industries and markets has mostly benefited pattern recognition, which is the capacity to identify what produces results in different situations consistently.

(In contrast to what works only once, for just one company, in just one particular situation, since they were able to take advantage of some short arbitrage to their benefit.)

We now employ the Planning PredictorTM framework for our businesses to assist derisk SEO and content planning so that we can concentrate only on what is currently projected to yield results with a high degree of reliability.

A high-level summary of the five selection criteria is given below:

  • Harvest demand: What, when, and why are your consumers looking for? Build out first keyword lists using top-down and bottom-up analytics, starting with relevance, volume, keyword difficulty (KD), and cost per click (CPC).
  • SERP competitiveness: How challenging are the corresponding SERPs, and are you realistically able to compete based on the quantity/quality of referring domains, as well as the average domain rating (DR), both now and in the future?
  • Current authority: Will you need to establish yourself as a subject matter expert in these fields, or are you already known for your expertise? (For example, are you already ranking for similar searches or running into a ceiling?)
  • Organic CTR: If competition for this keyword increases in the future, is it possible to expect to rank in the top three?
  • What are your preferred payback time frame and level of risk tolerance? (Zero to six months, six to twelve months, twelve to eighteen months, and so on.)

This may appear challenging at first, but it’s not if you know how to evaluate each. Therefore, let’s begin.

1. Harvest Demand

In the SEO industry, a proverb goes, “You can only harvest search demand.”

In other words, the vast majority of individuals on the planet (i.e., 99% of those reading this) will only be able to start from zero and develop a new category of searches. It’s too expensive and challenging.

Instead, the majority of our work involves figuring out what’s currently available, what’s already being looked for, and how that compares to both:

  • Our clients.
  • Our tools, goods, or services.

Consider the standard buyer’s journey or jobs-to-be-done procedure, where you examine the consumers’ decision-making processes when they:

  • Become conscious of an issue in their lives and the need to…
  • Look at potential solutions and the advantages and disadvantages of each before…
  • Choosing to get the appropriate remedy (hopefully yours).

Discovering all the potential issues, pain points, alternatives, and solutions your clients might experience is the result of this top-down investigation.

There should also be dozens to hundreds of potential keywords that can be targeted (or thousands if you have multiple customer personas, segments, products, or services).

The following step is to separate these into different types of variables, such as:

  • [Customer segment vertical] plus [pain point or issue]

Using [construction] with [project management], for instance:

  • The next step is to expand these initial keyword suggestions for all possible long-tail variations, taking into account each one’s relevance, volume, KD, and CPC.

(Fun fact: CPC can help identify keywords with higher potential purchase intent even though it is 100% focused on advertising.)

The results of a second example for “best socks” produce a massive list of similar terms that you may filter to reduce the signal-to-noise ratio for the things you are now most likely to rank for (relative to your site strength).

This is a combination of art and science. You’re trying to find hidden treasure. But first, there will be a ton of trash to sort through.

2. Competitivity in SERPs

Let me share a nasty little secret with you.

All SEO tools—even the most effective ones shown here—lie.

Not necessarily on purpose but out of necessity. Because what they’re attempting to accomplish, which is to copy and categorise what Google does, is quite challenging. almost impossible

Consider the “keyword difficulty” statistic as an example.

Understanding the perceived difficulty of possibly ranking for a keyword is useful. Nice in concept.

However, it is badly twisted in reality (where we all live).

As an illustration, a keyword may have an extremely low KD (such as “6” out of 100) but still be challenging to rank for. This is because it mainly employs connections as a proximate for strength (and page-level referring domains, at that).


Although the ranking sites’ domain-level strength (plus content quality) is very competitive, the average/median page-level referring domains may suggest the keyword is “less competitive.”

3. Topical Authority

Contrary to popular misconception, “inbound marketing” was not created by HubSpot.

About ten years ago, Seth Godin pioneered “permission marketing.” The Michelin Guide performed the same thing a century earlier.

What is outdated is updated.

Consider using pillars, clusters, hub-and-spoke models, or whatever your favourite marketing quack concocts next. These terms are semantics that have been applied to content hubs for many years.

(Originals like Ian Lurie have been harping on about these since most of today’s marketers were still in diapers.)

These “pillars,” “clusters,” or “whatevers” are related to site architecture and content hierarchies, forming dense webs of data that can help you become more of a subject-matter authority on particular topics.

Instead of making random grab bags out of new keywords and themes, you should carefully prepare them in bulk so you can structure them with internal links to create these silos.

For instance, the blog groups are subject according to particular industries of customers. Then, to assist enforce topical authority, they employ a parent-and-child hierarchy.

All boats rise with the tide.

You can rank higher and more quickly for related terms if you have topical authority.

However, the opposite is true: ranking will be more complex (more expensive and take longer) than individuals who already have authority.

So, consider this:

  • Are you currently ranked for terms similar to mine? If so, you most likely already possess some level of subject expertise. You are more likely to rank quickly with fresh content in this area the more content you have ranking higher in a particular cluster.
  • Instead of relying on the hazy, general aggregate scores that a random SEO tool spits out, you can use tools like the MarketMuse Inventory feature to analyse “personalised difficulty,” which helps predict your personalised topical authority (and, consequently, the difficulty of ranking for it).

4. Organic CTR

On a SERP, number 5 may equally well be position 50. Why?

Due to the practically identical quantity of traffic (read: nada, nada, nada!). Why?

Because the top three results usually generate roughly 70% of clicks, eyeballs, and, therefore, credit cards, according to SERP CTR research (the number of individuals who click on different locations).

(Remember that Pareto principle?)

This can be confirmed by looking at Advanced Web Ranking’s CTR research.

What does this mean, then?

It denotes:

  • Finishing in the top 3 is all that matters.
  • Picking less well-known, less competitive, and more relevant keywords will increase your chances of success (ranking top 3).
  • You can shorten the time to value and rank more items quickly (traffic, leads, sales).
  • Additionally, it means that to compete for the most valuable keywords in your industry, you either proliferate or leave your market and eat the leftovers of the competition.

Got it? Good.

So why is any of this significant?

Because comparing the costs and benefits of SEO vs content marketing is so straightforward:

  • How much would it cost you to be one of the top three results for a particular keyword?
  • And what could you gain if/when you do?

The keyword “international SEO” is a prime example. (In addition, there’s an excellent meta-reference you can’t miss.)

The following table compares the term’s potential volume, traffic potential, KD, number of links to rank, and CPC

Now. Do you have what it takes to crack the top 3 in the upcoming 12 to 24 months?

We must examine the SERP competitiveness to get a response to this question:

Pretty challenging

Especially in light of the meagre traffic, you would still receive even if you were in the top 3. Additionally, there is essentially no purchase intent.


Why would you even bother, even if you believed you had a chance to rank for this keyword in the upcoming 12 to 24 months (based on topical authority)?

It’s probably not worthwhile for 99% of websites unless you honestly marketed “international SEO” services or something close.

So, be sure to adapt your expectations.

  • Select a new subject and keyword to focus on.
  • Alternatively, build a massive site with sufficient topical authority and adjust your patience, spending, and timeline to someday rank for this keyword.

5. Payback Period

The most attention (and money) is paid to paid searches because

  • It’s straightforward to determine which keyword generates selective conversion and how much money you make.
  • Additionally, C-suites and marketers are lazy. (Perhaps just “impatient” will do.)

On the other hand, organic SEO and content both have a set payback period. But it’s frequently more difficult to track because it could take 6, 12, or even 18 months to see the total ROI.

Exhibit A: Ranking in the coveted top 3 position that generates all the pesos, yen, bitcoins, or whatever else, even for the biggest brands on the web, could take years:

Your task then is to determine the following:

  • Which keywords—the first four criteria stated in this article—are “worth” the “risk” or investment?
  • Will the projected return on investment justify the time, money, and resource commitment?
  • Can you wait until then to receive the reward?

This brings up a straightforward decision-making tree:

  • If the response is “Yes,” go ahead at full speed! Go big and bold, creating hundreds or even thousands of fresh content to rule your niche for the ensuing years (about 18 to 24 months).
  • If “Maybe” is the response, it’s time to think outside the box. Realistically, which new keywords and pieces of content can you focus on in the upcoming 12 months to bring about the outcomes that will enable you to increase your investment in the future?
  • If the response is “No,” it’s time to focus on what you already have to produce real momentum within the next six months. This usually involves updating existing material that ranks at the bottom of page one or the top of page two.

Simple, yes?

Actually, no.

Since this final section is purely subjective.

A lot depends on your role, organisation, internal advocates or stakeholders, general market conditions, and other potential external factors.

I’ve observed that most businesses fit into categories #2 or #3 above after dealing with hundreds of businesses over a decade. Only public companies and unicorns can breathe the rarefied air of position one.


Ranking today is challenging.

Unfortunately, it will only increase in cost and complexity with time.

Accordingly, most users outside the top 1% of the web must prioritise keywords and content if they want to see results in 6, 12, or 18 months.

Whether it’s from your boss, clients, spouse, or your intuition, demonstrating some short-term outcomes frequently buys you additional time and money to double down later.

Usually, this entails starting over at the beginning of this piece, going back to the drawing board, and then.

  • Changing your keyword choices under probable visitors and buying intent filters out more competitive terms,
  • To ensure that the domains and content you are competing with are as “simple” as the link-biased KD makes them out to be, you need to carefully examine SERP competition.
  • You are prioritising areas where you already have content that is ranked or where there is evidence of your topical authority in these areas and where you can consistently rank in the top three by producing enough content, gaining enough links, and improving the quality of your content faster than everyone else. If not, you should readjust your payback period expectations to persevere over time or engage in competition for more attainable, short-term goals.

It’s complex. Nothing can be “guaranteed.”

DMA Marketing Services churn out creative and one of a kind content with our skilled writers. We do consider the SEO success before the content creation so be rest-assured that your SEO will turn out well.

Want to join a community of other marketing experts & business owners to share, learn, and talk shop around all things accessibility? Follow us on LinkedIn, Facebook and Instagram.

Latest Articles

SEO copywriting is the practice of creating content that is not only engaging and informative but also optimized for search engines. It involves strategically …

User intent refers to the underlying motivation or purpose behind a user’s search query. It is the reason why someone is searching for a …

Meta descriptions are short snippets of text that appear below the title tag in search engine results pages (SERPs). They provide a brief summary …


Our certified digital marketing consultants will provide you with a FREE marketing consultation.


Our certified digital marketing consultants will provide you with a FREE marketing consultation.

Our Technology Partners

Call Us
Chat With Us
Contact Us